This is a generic rubric and student self reflection created to assess group discussion of all kinds. Online discussion rubric criteria unsatisfactory 0 limited 1 proficient 2 exemplary 3 score. Journal entry provides evidence of students use of readings, observations, and discussions to examine, appraise, compare. Each rubric was developed from the most frequently identified. Below are a variety resources helpful for introducing students to harkness discussions and for assessing harkness discussions and socratic seminars in the classroom. Insight into the reflection process is somewhat evident as the writer articulated what needs to be developed in the future. Evident that individual has not completed reading assignments prior to class. Each member of the group will submit their own commentary, summary and reflection. The questions case studies should be typed free rubric builder and assessment tools. Reflection essay rubric university of minnesota duluth. Assessment rubric for student reflections levels criteria reflective. Posts factually correct, reflective and substantive contribution. Use for book clubsliterature circles, research groups, etc. A student reflection should accompany each artifact and students should receive meaningful feedback for each artifact.
Replies lack substance and do not reflect any reading. Students understood activity sheet prompts and tables. Exhibits negative attitudes toward course and class members. Reflective essay rubric easy peasy allinone high school. A discursive analysis of observation debrief conversations between novice teach for america teachers and mentors article pdf available. This is an excellent and simple way to provide feedback for a discussion based learning environment to. Physics lab project rubric pdf evaluates a research project on the physics of kinematics. Review the learning outcome and associated criteria for success that this rubric will support. History of the americas internal assessment purpose of. Additionally, your response should provide a thoughtful discussion of the questions poised. Examples of discussion questions that may help to encourage reflection include the following.
Discussion rubric examples northwestern university. Explanation of concepts makes sense to an uninformed reader. A welldefined rubric will make marking of reflection systematic and support both you and. Class participation assessment rubric apprentice basic learned exemplary does not attend class on consistent basis. No discussion of how learning andor knowledge claims have confirmed, differed andor enhanced our theoretical andor practical understanding of an issue or phenomenon needs. Reflect on the concepts discussed in this learning block and then answer the following questions in a journal reflection a few sentences per question. Discussion rubrics teaching online pedagogical repository. Very few grammatical, spelling or punctuation errors interfere with reading the paper. You will answer these questions using your textbook, notes and other resources to further your knowledge and understanding of the material. The original value initiative in involved teams of faculty and other educational professionals to develop 16 value rubrics for the leap essential learning outcomes. Does not contribute to class discussions or inclass activities. Within a week following the end of the assigned discussion, each leader will submit an evaluation and a reflection. Reflective writing rubric midcentral district health board.
Minimal or no discussion reflection on content knowledge or preparedness for lesson. Offers few opinions and makes limited connections to the text. Reflection this section of the internal assessment task requires students to reflect on what undertaking their investigation highlighted to them about the methods used by, and the challenges facing, the historian. Arrangement of classroom supported student collaboration and teacher facilitation. Rubric for article summary and reaction papers article summary criteria target acceptable unacceptable main points all main points of the article are summarized accurately and thoroughly. While this is a discussion not a paper the writing and organization of your response should be at the same level as one would expect to find in a paper. Rubric to assess service learning reflection papers developed.
Journal entry provides evidence of students use of readings, observations, and discussions to examine, appraise, com pare, contrast, plan for new actions or. The reader can create a mental picture of the situation being described. Benchmark 1 milestone 2 milestone 3 capstone 4 score intention ebc 1. Applied learning critical reflection scoring rubric. Reflection lab included, labeled and organized all parts of the lab report. Scs 100 learning block 33 journal reflection rubric. Rubric for student reflections above expectations meets expectations approaching expectations below expectations 4 3 2 1 reflective thinking as well as vague andor the reflection explains the students own thinking and learning processes, implications for future learning.
Your selfreflection should connect your learning to specific aspects of the experience, the learning should be significant and relevant, and statements should be based on evidence and supported with examples. Online discussion rubric criteria unsatisfactory 0 limited 1 proficient 2 exemplary 3 score critical analysis understanding of readings and outside references discussion postings show little or no evidence that readings were completed or understood. Selfreflection minimally reflection on experiences, learning, practices, and understandings. This reflection can be used as an example for other students. This rubric may be used for selfassessment and peer feedback. The original value initiative in 200709 involved teams of faculty and other educational professionals from over 100 higher education institutions engaged over many months to develop 16 value rubrics for the leap essential learning outcomes. Determine the numeric scale and its terminology for the top row e. Scs 100 learning block 33 journal reflection rubric prompt. Describe an example of a behavior that is impacted by socialization and cultural. Jimenez, and beckett 2010 found that even doctoral students may need explicit grading instructions, and therefore provide rubrics and sample responses while not stifling creativity p. Offers few opinions and makes no personal connections to the text. Every week you will be asked to reflect on and respond to at least one discussion board question and post your contribution to the topic on the discussion board. Drafts of each rubric were then tested by faculty with their own students work on over. Is unable to engage in any discussion about aesthet ics is encyclopedic in any discussion of aesthetics, using the language of lectures and texts appropriately, but reveals no personal views or ideas.
A comparative analysis of reflection and selfassessment. A comparative analysis of reflection and selfassessment melissa desjarlais1, peter smith2 abstract reflection is a personal process that can deepen ones understanding of self and can lead to significant discoveries or insights, while. Rubrics and reflection a portfolio is a collection of artifacts that represent student growth and learning. About 15002000 words, 810 pages double spaced, 30 points. This posting does not reflect that the student did or. Throughout this process, the teacher assesses every student in groups of four or five, using the rubric.
Creating and using rubrics for assessment university of. Research paper grading rubric university of kansas. This guide is a brief compilation of teachingrelated information from several sources, including instructional guidebooks from other institutions, journals, and contributions from master teachers and academic support units at northern illinois university. This list is meant to be a repository of ideas and materials and it represents the contributions of many experienced educators. Student expresses awareness of issues pertaining to oneonone connection on the project. This is an excellent and simple way to provide feedback for a discussion based learning environment to students and parents. Video selfreflection assignment updated 1020 performance items to include in reflection unacceptable 01 acceptable 23 target 45 was my content knowledge appropriate and evident for this lesson. Demonstrates ability to work with peers and host teacher.
Reflective writing rubric skills 5 4 3 2 1 depth of reflection demonstrate a conscious and thorough understanding of the writing prompt and the subject matter. Pdf reflection in learning is a popular and widely studied concept. Generic assessment rubric unsw teaching staff gateway. Reflection methodology discussion selfassessment methodology discussion step 1. Discussion leadership group leadership evaluation and. The foll owing rubric has been developed based on a number of frameworks that describe levels of. Pdf validation of a reflection rubric for higher education. The reflection explains the students thinking about hisher own. Value rubric development project association of american. Discussion board reflection course grading see rubrics below weekly reflection 40 the reflection to be posted on the discussion board and comment to 3 peers 10 points each learning activity 48 strategytoolsupports implemented into the classroom 12 points each portfolio 12 the portfolio should be considered a living document that. Online discussion rubric criteria unsatisfactory 0 limited 1 proficient 2 exemplary 3 score critical analysis understanding of readings and outside references discussion postings show little or no evidence that readings were completed or. Using reflection for service learning and community. The current study provides preliminary support for a reflection rubric. The reflection leaves an impression on the reader about what the student learned.
Each rubric was developed from the most frequently identified characteristics or criteria of learning for each of the 16 learning outcomes. Reflection writing rubric sophisticated a very competent b fairly competent c not yet competent d accuracy grasp of readings paper represents the authors ideas, evidence or conclusions accurately, fairly and eloquently. Guidelines for scoring an expository written reflection free rubric builder and assessment tools. Demonstrate a thoughtful understanding of the writing prompt and the subject matter. While faculty might hope that students can just discuss a topic online with little or no support, beckett, amaro. The seven reflection and evaluation rubrics are designed for teachers and their students to use at the beginning of a lesson design and again at the end of the lesson cycle to evaluate the progress of learners after applying the 21. Checklist for creating a rubric follow the steps in the checklist below to create your rubric. Discussion of the concept of change can encourage sophisticated discussions such as encouraging students to think about, and look for, change where some claim none exists, or using evidence to challenge orthodox theories. Discussion leadership group leadership evaluation and reflection. Rubric for original research project cornell college. Fails to meet this criteria by obvious disregard for the expectations stated in the criteria. Your self reflection should connect your learning to specific aspects of the experience, the learning should be significant and relevant, and statements should be based on evidence and supported with examples. History of the americas internal assessment purpose of internal assessment. Literature circle assessment rubric level one level two level three level four discussion does not participate in group discussions.
Write down something a peer shared during the discussion that you found interesting or. Selfreflection tool id resource description intended audience l1a teacher video selfie module a guided instructional module for teachers to practice effective selfreflection teachers l1b selfanalysis rubric a simple rubric for teachers to assess whether theyve filtered out noisy or. Your professor may use a slightly different rubric, but the standard rubric at aur will. The reflection is an indepth analysis of the learning experience, the value of the derived learning to self or others, and the enhancement of the students. Planning and preparation component beginning emerging compromising collaborating planning prior to implementation team has not discussed or agreed upon any issues before beginning.
Data section includes provided graphic with incident and reflected rays for several paths at least two. Instructions to students examples from two instructors example 1. Leveraging video for learning center for education. Rubric to assess service learning reflection papers developed by hawaii campus compact awareness of purpose of service novice apprentice proficient distinguished student demonstrates limited awareness of the purpose of obtaining sl credit. Instructional guide niu center for innovative teaching. Contributes to discussion with clear, concise comments formatted in an easy to read style that is free of grammatical or spelling errors. What sort of cultural or social forces impact how we think and behave. Reflection as a tool for selfassessment is an integral part of the learning. Science observation and discussion rubric pdf scientific report rubric easy to modify for any kind of high school research report. Reflection discussion grading rubric expectations for the reflection discussion. Discussion leadership with group evaluation and reflection on online learning using discussion forums. Demonstrate a conscious and thorough understanding of the writing prompt and the subject. In this paper we will perform a comparative analysis of reflection and selfassessment, clarifying the differences in definition. A discursive analysis of observation debrief conversations between novice teach for america teachers and mentors article pdf available february 2017 with 169 reads.
1209 950 312 457 19 534 694 140 939 670 325 521 642 55 256 1285 1166 867 342 1092 113 1655 1173 1037 697 1463 322 274 654 1401 347 1072 727 114 21